What Hard Times Reveal

Forbes.com recently published some interesting survey data from consulting firm Towers Perrin about How Workers Feel Right Now. Here are the numbers:

  • Engagement is up one to two points from 2008
  • Efficiency is up eight points
  • The feeling that management is giving people a clear sense of direction is down from 71% to 63%
  • Understanding of company goals fell from 79% to 69%
  • Understanding of department goals fell from 83% to 71%

If you look at what’s happened to the economy and the workplace in the past years, these numbers make sense. It’s a snapshot of downsizing, fear, and confusion:

  • Engagement goes up because people are afraid of losing their jobs.
  • Efficiency goes up because there are fewer people doing the same amount of work.
  • Understanding of goals and expectations goes down because our work culture is based on time and abstractions like “dedication.”

That drop in department goals clarity is really telling (and deadly). It shows that the long boom masked a lot of dodgy management. Because if you’re making your numbers and you’re having even a little bit of success, then you don’t really have to question what you’re doing. It’s only when times turn sour that an organization starts to ask itself, “What are we doing?”

Right now we’re hearing stories from people who feel lucky to have a job, but feel completely at sea. Their bosses—who are used to managing time and not results—don’t know what to do other than issue vague commands like “let’s really buckle down” and “we need to work hard here, people” and “let’s all make sure we’re extra available and responsive.”

The work culture that allowed these kinds of statements to pass as acceptable may be gone forever. While we don’t welcome the human cost of the global economic crisis, we do hope that our current woes provide an opportunity to emerge in better shape than when we entered.

  • Liz

    This baffles me:

    http://www.cnbc.com/id/31185763//

    “Why Telecomuting is Tough for Small Companies”

    I agree that building a strong relationship with new hires and among coworkers is important. That will aide in streamlining the virtual communication process. But telling people (who you first told could work from home) to come into the office more often (because you can’t manage to come up with a strong virtual communication strategy) is just nonsense.

    Its really sad when people keep writing articles like this. But since I’ve read the ROWE book twice now, I can always find where the anti-rowe argument breaks down.

  • Concerned employee

    The environment we are living in today puts people in a survival mode. This crisis invites managers to show productivity by controlling employees’ time more closely. The message becomes clear that staying busy and putting in extra time sitting in your cubicle is important. This is a reaction to a crisis and it becomes expensive and counter-productive.

  • Matt

    @Liz – Sometimes it’s funny to read these types of articles. When someone has come to the realization that results are all that matter, comments like those in the article no longer bear weight as coming from “experience”, but personal preference instead.

    The best example in his article of personal preference is stating that email communication and coordination is ‘a recipe for errors and misunderstanding’ in comparison to face-to-face dialogue. Yeah, sure… a written record of what was discussed is nowhere near as accurate and comprehensible as talking to someone who (proven by scientific study) already has forgotten some of the things you said by the end of the conversation.

    I was also dumbfounded at the notion of having a company retreat just to get people together with no real purpose. Uh, instead of wasting money on a company covered vacation, why wouldn’t he spend it on security measures to deal with the homeless issue rather than worrying about having enough employees to take care of it?

    I’m sorry, but the article should have been titled “I Hate Using Email and Phones – How to Operate Like an Industrial Age Factory in the Digital Age”. It would have been more honest.

  • http://blog.conmergence.com Ed Dodds

    Yep, THIS is why everyone in public policy keeps yapping about a greater Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) Education infrastructure — because we wouldn’t want to be able to use all the new fangled technology for say rural economic development when it violates one guy’s sensibilities. Everyone knows that America’s business engine is built on keeping mediocre middle management (and those who have been promoted out of it to their appropriate level of incompetence) coddled lest, God forbid, they figure out how to put their business model/requirements/workflow in digital format and risk being rightsized like the folks below them. Why, in that crazy world, folks will one day be demanding “say on pay” of the C-Suite and transparency and other dangerous to capitalism ideas ;-) Tangent: Any list of ROWE tweeters anywhere?

  • Pingback: Are your SMART Goals still relevant? | Cube Rules