The Reward for Work Done Well…

"Time to Think Out of the Box", by Frits Ahlefeldt

Traditional managers (and workers) insist: if an employee is a high performer and completes his (or her) work quickly and efficiently, then he should be expected to do more work.

This is rewarded in the traditional work environment using, as a measure, the “face time” a person has accumulated either at his desk or with his “higher-ups”. High performance marks are granted to those who put in the most time.

If Susan comes in early and stays late, then she is clearly “dedicated” or “committed”. She must be if she is there all the time, spending hours with the “right” people, if she only takes half a lunch, and diligently pecks away at her keyboard (when someone important is looking).

No. Wrong.

The reward for work done well… should not be MORE work (usually somebody else’s, who has fallen behind in their work). Rewarding your high performers by commanding them to do the additional work of your slackers is not a reward at all. That is punishment.

It IS a reward, though, to the slackers. They have no pressure or responsibility to perform better. It is okay to slack because someone else will fix their mistakes, complete whatever tasks they do not, and pick up the extra work when they want to kick back.

Again, the reward for work done well should not be more work.

The reward for work done well… should be more FREEDOM.

Instead of punishing high performers, what if, once employees meet their results, they are free to do whatever they want? Think about it. ROWE is like turbo-charging your team, switching from regular unleaded to high octane fuel.

Most cars (jobs) run on regular (traditional) gas and they chug along okay. Nothing wrong with regular; it’s regular, traditional; it’s what almost everybody else does. It only becomes not okay when a race car (competitor) suddenly zips by. It has a better engine, better fuel, and is able to achieve higher speed and increased performance. It’s quick, efficient, and dazzling, and now the 87 octane looks like a horse and carriage by comparison.

In a ROWE, the default setting is high-octane. The high performers get the rewards—they get to the result (winning) faster and they enjoy the ensuing benefits (more time with friends and family, more control over their lives, etc.). The slackers do not get rewarded. They get left in the dust. After all, Nascar never sends the winning car around the track a few more times to push the other cars along. Other cars can still run on regular if that is their preference but they get the same results regular cars get. The race car gets the results race cars get. Very simple.

Here is what many traditional leaders miss…

If the slackers start seeing the high performers rewarded with more freedom instead of punished with more work, what happens? You can probably guess. Slackers now have incentive to step up their game, to tune up their engine and become star performers. They will want the reward that properly comes with work done well. In a Results-Only Work Environment, slackers do not get to loaf because there is no incentive to do so.

The other thing that happens is high performers become even higher performers. They no longer hate their jobs. They stop doing great work out of a personal sense of duty and start doing their absolute best work from a sense of passion for doing what they love (which is possibly why they chose the job in the first place). The race cars love their freedom and their inclination is to protect it, to show you they never want it to go away. They become loyal, resourceful, powerful, and inspired.

When you start legitimately rewarding work done well and throw out the fake platitudes and the watch in exchange for 20 years of service (really? I give you 20 years of my life that can never be returned and you give me a ^#*$% watch?), then EVERYONE focuses on results.

The surprising thing is, when you go ROWE, many of the people you know to be slackers right now will turn into high performers, and some of the people you thought were high performers turn out to be slackers who were just talented at gaming the system. In a ROWE, the real slackers are exposed and the real high performers are brought forward. If a company is really, truly, committed to blowing away the competition and getting to results, there is an easy and obvious way to do it.

Turbo charge your organization. Set your performers free.

Go ROWE!

Tags: , , , , ,

  • http://eveglass.livejournal.com Julie

    This is such a hot-button issue for me. (In fact, it was one of the reasons I left my last job.) Thanks for bringing it up.

    • Cali & Jody

      Julie – this is a hot button issue for so many people. We see the frustration all over when we’re working with teams to move them into a ROWE. What kinds of things were happening at your last job? The fact that you left gives us an inkling as to how bad it was, but were there any steps being taken to improve the situation?

    • http://michaelsalamey.com Michael Salamey

      My pleasure, Julie.

  • Dhanam Prakash

    I am a ROWE devotee without question and hope that one day I get to work in a ROWE.

    From the non-ROWE side of things this is what we experience at work.

    Top-level management sets unrealistic expectations about how much work can be completed in a given period of time. This puts the pressure on middle-level managers to achieve those results. They don’t care who completes the work as long as the work gets done. In my team we do not have slackers. All of us work hard and sincerely (I am not talking about face-time or currying favor with the higher-ups, our focus is getting the job done) but there is too much work to do. Until recently I would say that our manager was a stealth-ROWE manager. As long as we got the work done she was happy and did not care if we came in to the office or worked from elsewhere. Actually in one sense that is still true. Even now all she cares about is the work getting done but in reality the all of us could work non-stop 24/7 and still not make the targets.
    I really like the technical challenges this job has to offer. I just wish I had the time to address them cleanly instead of working in emergency mode all the time and still not feeling satisfied that I did a good day’s work at the end of the day.

    I am seriously thinking about taking a few days of vacation and using it to work. If not anything else I can get some things done to my satisfaction and feel good about it.

    More power to the culturerx team and others like you.

    • Cali & Jody

      Dhanam – yes, the work is never done, and that is a reality. In our experience, we find that it’s the way the work is happening that’s the real culprit. You mention perhaps taking a vacation in order to get some work done…that feeling of doing work the way you need to (where and when included) is the key. You know that if you were to “take a vacation” that you’d feel good about how you were approaching things and that you’d be productive beyond belief.

      The issue of unrealistic expectations is definitely a problem. One of the ways ROWE combats this is by setting a foundation for everyone to ask the questions “how will that affect our outcome?” and “how will that be measured?” There are so many times when leadership makes requests, but their focus isn’t on the overall outcome – it’s on making sure people continue to look busy.

      ROWE forces the right questions and, in turn, leaders realize they can’t expect middle managers/ employees to just blindly say “yes” to everything they want done.

      It’s quite the cycle to break, but do you see things happening in the culture that might start moving things in the right direction?

  • http://www.twitter.com/VibrantHR Lacey

    Well-said! High-performers usually like to take on new things…for the right reasons. But if they’re given more work because they’re efficient and have “extra time” to fill, then it feels like punishment.

    • Cali & Jody

      Lacey – well said! “I’m afraid you’re just too efficient – time for your punishment. Create these 6 reports for me by the end of the day [that, by the way, no one will ever look at].” Absolutely insane!

  • KellyK

    I love the point that the reward for hard work shouldn’t be more work. Back in college, when I worked in food service part time, I remember cleaning the same counter over and over so I didn’t get in trouble for “not working”–and worse, get assigned some thoroughly unpleasant task because I wasn’t busy. And resenting the heck out of my fellow students who worked at the library and the help desk. When they had no work to do during their shifts, they got to catch up on their homework.

    • Cali & Jody

      Kelly – I remember doing something similar in a retail store I worked at. Folding the same shirt over and over so I wouldn’t be called on to do some extremely hideous task. Although, folding the same shirt over and over is quite hideous now that I think about it!

    • http://michaelsalamey.com Michael Salamey

      Wow, “cleaning the same counter over and over so I didn’t get in trouble for not working” paints a vivid picture.

      I look forward to the day when that seems like the dark ages.

  • Jenn

    What another, spot-on post! My unofficial title at work is “Queen of Crappy Projects” for exactly this reason. I am even the one requesting more work; since I can’t leave when I am done (or choose when or where I’d work), I’d rather be productive. Looking forward to more ROWE companies on the East Coast! Keep up the good work everyone!

    • Cali & Jody

      And it’s people like you, Jenn, that should be *rewarded* with your own time, not punished with crappy projects!! You want to be productive…a good thing. But you also don’t want to be chained to a place where you’re not productive every single minute. Imagine that :)

      East Coast companies in a ROWE – they’re coming. And if you hear of any that have interest, you know where to send them…